Our Menu
Cakes
Very Strawberry
White cake filled with strawberry butter cream and fresh strawberries, finished with vanilla buttercream
Passion
White cake filled with passion fruit buttercream and fresh raspberries, finished with our vanilla buttercream and fresh raspberries
Lemony Lemon
Lemon pound cake soaked with fresh lemon syrup, filled and finished with white chocolate cream cheese
Colin's Peanut Butter Wags
Chocolate cake, filled with peanut butter buttercream and milk chocolate buttercream, finished with chocolate ganache
Chocolate Toffee
Our most popular cake! Chocolate cake filled with caramel buttercream and crunchy toffee chunks, iced smooth with chocolate ganache and topped with chocolate buttercream and toffee
Reverse German
Chocolate cake filled with traditional German coconut, pecan caramel icing, iced smooth with chocolate ganache topped with chocolate buttercream, a sprinkle of coconut and pecans
Mom's Yellow Cake
Yellow cake filled and finished with our chocolate buttercream icing, iced with traditional swirly spatula marks and topped with chocolate shavings
Red Velvet Raspberry
A Southern tradition made the classic way with buttermilk and a touch of cocoa, filled and finished with white chocolate cream cheese and fresh raspberries
Black and White Chocolate
Layers of our white cake and chocolate cake filled with white chocolate cream cheese icing, one layer of chocolate ganache and iced smooth with more chocolate ganache, finished with chocolate buttercream and a drizzle of white chocolate
Plain Jane
Vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream and an edible and delicious flower icing top
Cheesecakes
We ask for a 72 hour notice for cheesecakes (individual or 9"). All 9" cheesecakes have a GF option. The individual vanilla cheesecake is always GF.
Vanilla Cheesecake
With fresh berries, graham crust
Caramel Apple
Vanilla cheesecake, caramelized apples, cinnamon crumble topping, caramel drizzle
Chocolate Addiction
Chocolate cheesecake, brownie crust, chocolate ganache
Strawberry Love
Strawberry cheesecake, fresh strawberries, graham crust
Peanut Butter Cup
Peanut butter cheesecake, house-made peanut butter cups, peanut butter brownie crust
Pies
What we've noticed is that people who love a certain pie, whatever pie it is, for example, cherry, strawberry rhubarb, apple crumble or key lime, what they'll say is that ours is the best they've ever had.
Cherry Lattice Pie
Sour Michigan cherries baked into the best buttery lattice crust you’ll ever have. The classic interwoven lattice top is a true American delight
Apple Crumbly Pie
Caramelized spiced apples with a crumble top
Betty's Berry Crumble Pie
Blueberries, blackberries and raspberries with a crumble top
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Strawberries and tangy rhubarb in our buttery lattice crust
Pecan Pie
Gooey, butterscotchy, and chock full of pecans this pie is baked with a whole lotta’ love in our signature butter crust
Chocolate Cookie Dough Pie
Two kinds of rich chocolate chips, and toffee bits, stud our gooey cookie dough, baked in a chocolate or shortbread crust...this pie will satisfy your inner cookie monster!
Apple Lattice Pie
Banana Cream Pie
Berry Lattice Pie (GF)
Blackberries, blueberries and raspberry pie in a gluten free pie crust
Chocolate Cream Pie
Chocolate cream filling in a gluten free sugar cookie crust with whipped cream topping.
Chocolate Pecan Pie
Available Oct to December only. If you like pecan pie and you like dark semi-sweet chocolate, you'll love this pie.
Coconut Cream Pie
Coconut cream filling with a coconut flake topping.
Key Lime Pie
Sweet and tart, just the way it should be.
Mississippi Mud Pie
Chocolate brownie bits, caramel, marshmallow and a chocolate crust. Wow.
Pumpkin Pie
Available October to December. With or without whipped cream.
Bars
Butterscotch Pecan Blondie Bar
Baked with caramel swirls
St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake Bar
St. Louis tradition! Moist buttery cake with sweet cream cheese custard topped with fresh berries!
Turtle Brownie
With pecans, caramel and chocolate drizzle
Lemon Pie Bar
Topped with white chocolate cream cheese buttercream
Mexican Brownie
Spiked with cinnamon
Magic Bar
Coconut, 3 kinds of Belgian chocolate chips, pecans, almonds
Cheesecake Brownie
Baked with chocolate chips and topped with a chocolate drizzle
Caramel Pecan Bar
With a shortbread crust, dipped in milk chocolate
Cakey Brownie
One of our most popular items. Perfect for everyday use. Exceptional quality and choice
Cookies
Paula's Sugar Cookie
Sugar cookie topped with colorful buttercream flowers
Chocolate Toffee Cookie
Semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips with house-made toffee
Oatmeal Raisin Walnut Cookie
Oatmeal raisin walnut cookie with maple glaze
Ginger Molasses Cookie
Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate Cookie
Cupcakes
Ho' Daddy
Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream
Plain Jane
White cake with pink vanilla buttercream roses
Rosie's Red Velvet
Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting
Beeze-Knees
Chocolate cake with honey buttercream, dipped in milk chocolate
Black & White
Chocolate marble cake with vanilla buttercream dipped in milk chocolate
Grasshopper
Chocolate cake with mint buttercream dipped in milk chocolate
Chocolate Toffee
Chocolate cake with caramel buttercream dipped in milk chocolate and topped with toffee bits
Colin's Peanut Butter Wags
Chocolate cake with peanut butter buttercream dipped in milk chocolate topped with salty peanuts
Salted Caramel
Caramel cupcake with caramel buttercream and sea salt
Churro
Cinnamon spiced cupcake with cream cheese icing and crunchy cinnamon sugar
Sunshine Cake
White cake with passionfruit buttercream and a yellow rose
Strawberry Kiss
Our special white cake with strawberry buttercream
Coconut
Coconut cake with cream cheese icing and sweet coconut flakes
German Chocolate
Chocolate cake with coconut pecan icing
Morning Delights
At the 50's cafe
Mr. Checker's Cheddar Biscuit
Seriously yummy
Rosetta's Scone
Lemon glazed cranberry scone
Roy-O Rollie
Brioche cinnamon roll topped with cream cheese icing. Now available every day
Barry's Berry Buckle
A coffee cake like no other. This version has blueberries, blackberries and raspberries
Happy Days Frutti Parfait
Wop boy b'luma b'lop bam boom! Vanilla yogurt, GF granola, strawberries, raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries. (GF with a Vegan option)
Ray's Peach Parfait
Vanilla yogurt, GF granola, peach pie compote (GF with a Vegan option)
Earth Angel Oatmeal
GF rolled oats, apple pie compote, and a dash of cinnamon-sugar
Breakfast
All items in tis menu are served frozen "take and bake" unless "hot and ready" is requested in advance (phone or order online).
Johnny's Country Breakfast
Eggs, turkey bacon, poultry sausage, cheddar cheese, potatoes, green onions, biscuit pastry
June's Veggie Pie
Spinach, mushrooms, green onions, potatoes, asiago cheese, biscuit pastry (Veg)
Patsy's Hand Pie
Eggs, ham, swiss and potatoes in an enclosed herb and garlic pastry shell
Lunch & Dinner
All items in tis menu are served frozen "take and bake" unless "hot and ready" is requested in advance (phone or order online).
I Love Lucy's Chicken Pot Pie
Our signature herb pastry chicken pie, with peas, carrots, celery and tender chicken breast, in a creamy veloute
Italian Turkey Meatball Pie
Housemade marinara, mozzarella, parmesan and turkey meatballs on a pizza dough crust
Thanksgiving Parade Pot Pie
Layers of roasted turkey, gravy, mashed potatoes, green beans, stuffing with a side of cranberry chipotle sauce
Roger's Cowpoke Handpie
Spicy bbq chicken, red onion and cheddar chipotle pastry
Grace's Greens (veg) Handpie
Spinach, kale, mushroom, parmesan, and mozzarella
Sophia's Italian Pizza Handpie
Pepperoni, mozzarella, house marinara
Drinks
Hot Teas
Chai, Earl Grey, English Breakfast, Green Tea
Hot Coffees
Drip, Americano, Latte, Mocha
100% Fruit Juices
Apple, Orange
Iced Teas
Black Unsweetened, Green Unsweetened, Sweet Peach, Arnold's 50/50 Tea & Lemonade
House Made Lemonades
Regular, Blackberry, Peach, Strawberry
Milk
Regular, Chocolate, Oat
Bottled Water
There Is a 2 Dozen Minimum per Flavor. Requires 72 Hours Advance Notice, Subject to Availability. GF-Gluten free
Pie Bites
Pecan
Cherry
Berry Crumble
Strawberry Rhubarb
Apple Crumble
Coconut Cream
Banana Cream
Mississippi Mud
Key Lime
Chocolate Cream (GF)
Mixed Berry Double-Crust (GF)
Bar Bites
Cakey Brownie
Butterscotch Pecan Blondie
Lemon Pie Bar
Magic Bar
Mexican Bar
Gooey Butter Cake
Double Chocolate (GF, V)
Dipped on A Stick
Chocolate Dipped